Crispy Air fryer fingerling potatoes recipe

Air fryer fingerling potatoes (Fingerling potatoes in air fryer)

Potatoes are some of the recipes that are best made in the air fryer because they turn out perfectly cooked and in less time than any other methods with similar outcome. These air fryer fingerling potatoes never disappoint.

Whether roasted fingerling potatoes are served as a standalone or with steak or eggs, you will definitely be making these again because they are so good.

Did you know that Rosemary is one of the best herbs to include in your potato seasoning it’s adds a depth of flavor that can’t be matched.

What are fingerling potatoes?

Fingerling potatoes are small, elongated and somewhat stubby looking potatoes that look like they are shaped like fingers. These are fully grown potatoes and shouldn’t be confused with baby potatoes or new potatoes that are harvested before they are fully grown.

They can be boiled, baked, smashed, fried or air fried. They can be used in recipes where any potato species can be used.

Why you’ll love this recipe

• Super easy to make! This is a perfectly beginner friendly air fryer recipe.
• Potatoes are Budget friendly and versatile.
• Roasted fingerling potatoes Family friendly and picky eater approved.
• Vegan and vegetarian and a great option for meatless Mondays.

Ingredients

• Fingerling potatoes
• Oil
• Garlic powder
• Paprika
• Salt
• Fresh Rosemary
• Onion powder

Substitutions

Type of Potato: Any potato would work for this recipe. You can use Baby potatoes, heirloom potatoes, Irish potatoes, russet potatoes or golden potatoes. If using larger potatoes simply cut into cubes.

Seasoning: You can use any mix of seasoning and herbs you like. You can even use specialty seasoning blends like Suya spice, Cajun seasoning etc.

How long to air fry fingerling potatoes?

Air fryers differ in how long it takes to cook food. Preheating the air fryer will result in a relatively faster outcome without including the preheat time.

These air fryer fingerling potatoes got ready in 18 mins at 400°F / 200°C in my Cosori 5.8qt air fryer.

How to make roasted air fryer fingerling potatoes.

This is an overview of the recip with step by step photos. Scroll down to end of post for a printable recipe card with the amount of ingredients and full recipe instructions.

Wash potatoes thoroughly especially if you intend to cook it skin on. Pat dry then cut in halves.

Add oil then season with salt and the other ingredients listed. Mix until combined. Transfer to air fryer basket or rack and air fry at 400°F / 200°C for 18 to 20 mins

What to serve with fingerling potatoes

Fingerling potatoes can be served on its own or with a dipping sauce like fry sauce. It goes well with scrambled eggs, haddock fish, chicken wings, drumsticks, thighs or chicken breasts. You could also serve these with salads and coleslaw.

Have you tried potatoes and sausage or even with green beans and bacon. These Brussels sprouts recipe with potatoes is also a winner. To be honest the side dish options for this recipe are endless.

How to store and reheat

Air Fingerling potatoes can be made ahead of time and leftovers store very well. This is a great addition to your air fryer meal prep ideas.

To store simply let the spuds cool completely then store is a dry and clean airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 5 days. I don’t recommend freezing this recipe.

Reheating air fryer fingerling potatoes

This can either be done in the microwave or in the air fryer

Microwave: Place in a paper towel lined microwave safe plate and microwave on high at 30 secs intervals till warmed through.

Air fryer: Transfer potatoes to air basket or rack, set temperature to 350°F / 180°C and air fry for 4 to 6 mins or until warmed through.

Best Tips for air fryer fingerling potatoes

• You can air fry fingerling potatoes whole or sliced into halves or quartered into cubes.
• No need to preheat the air fryer
• If you are keeping the skin on like I did, please wash thoroughly or buy organic whenever you can.

FAQs

Here you’ll find answers to common questions about this recipe. If your question isn’t answered, please leave us a comment below and we’ll gladly answer them.

Do you need to poke potatoes before air frying?

You do not need to poke potatoes before air frying particularly not necessary for small potatoes like fingerlings or baby potatoes.

How long are potatoes supposed to be in the air fryer.

The length of time depends on the size and soecie of the potatoes and also the brand of air fryer being used. Generally smaller potatoes or potatoes that have been cubed will cook faster than whole potatoes.

Where to buy fingerling potatoes

These potatoes can be found in grocery stores across the United States. You can buy fingerling potatoes at Walmart, ACME, Stop & Shop or any other grocery store. One of my favorite brands are the Little potato company fingerling potatoes.